In the FOC reflector, there has been a discussion going on regarding sending CW. Some people claim that we should send accurate CW with proper dot dash ratio and spacing for some time. It helps the listeners to read us easier.
The problem may be divided into two aspects. CW sending should be accurate as if it were sent by keyboard. Dot dash ratio should be exactly 1:3 while there should be proper spacing between characters/words. The other problem is that such mechanically accurate sending is often boring to our ears. We appreciate musical rhythm in CW. It varies in time. We often feel comfortable with something exquisitely changing. It may reflect our heart beats. Anyway, that is why CW is called as an art.
Even though I admitted that such a discussion is not meaningless and is quite right, I felt a bit reluctant to go on such a discussion. This is the reason why I feel that way as shown in this post in the reflector.
Quote;
Everyone、
In my view, there are two points which make me reluctant to discuss
about this problem.
Firstly, this problem is often critical since recognition of bad keying
could be subjective. Certain keying could be artistic to some
operator s while it sounds like a mess to the other, depending on
the capability of reception.
Secondly, another difficulty to discuss about keying is that some
operators have physical or even mental problems which prevent
them from sending appropriately. It is not courteous nor beneficial
to comment on their keying since it is almost impossible for them
to improve it.
However, there seem to be the case of anosodiaphoria. The operator
could have improved keying but are not conscious of the problem with
their keying. In this case, we should tell them it is difficult for us to read
them. It may let them realize the problem with their keying.
With this anosodiaphoria, they won't record their own keying etc. Our
candidate report must be the only thing to help them realize it. Maybe,
no use to discuss about it in the recflector.
Let me realize it when my keying sounds sloppy. I will try not to be
cranky at such a report.
Shin
JA1NUT